← All articles
Nov 7, 20267 min readLer em português

The Profit That Never Existed

When vacation pay, the 13th salary and severance aren't accrued monthly to the right project, the job looks profitable, the profit gets distributed, and the bill arrives after the job has closed.

Crew hard hats and work gloves hanging beside a closed ledger and calculator in a site office, in late-afternoon light.

The job is finished. The result was good. The margin came in close to the estimate, the client paid on time, and the partners decided to distribute part of the profit.

Six months later, that job's crew is demobilized. Then come the severance payments, the accrued vacation, the prorated 13th salary, the FGTS penalty. The bill is large. And it lands on a company that has already distributed the money that should have paid it.

That job's profit never existed. It only seemed to exist because part of the cost hadn't been recorded yet.

The cost that arrives later

Every payroll has two parts. The first is this month's wages, which everyone sees and pays. The second is the cost that same worker generates for the future, which only leaves the bank account later.

In Brazil, that second part is large. For every month worked, an employee accrues:

None of this is news to the payroll department. The problem is where and when that cost is recorded.

When the cost doesn't stay on the right job

In many construction companies, vacation, the 13th salary and severance are recorded when they're paid, not when they're incurred. The 13th salary hits in November and December. Vacation, when the employee takes it. Severance, when the job ends and the crew is demobilized.

That creates three distortions:

  • The job in progress looks more profitable than it is. It uses labor every month but only carries the wages. The cost that's piling up doesn't show in its result.
  • The cost goes to the wrong job. When the 13th salary is paid in December, it's charged to whatever job the employee is on that month, even if he worked the whole year on another.
  • The final bill lands in a generic cost center. Severance for a demobilized crew often goes to "overhead" or "general costs," and the job that generated that cost closes with a result that isn't real.

The combined effect is predictable. Jobs look better than they are while they're running. Profit is recognized too early. And the decisions made from it — distributing results, pricing the next job, hiring more people — start from a number that doesn't exist.

Why it hurts more in construction

Every company with employees has this cost. In construction, it weighs more for three reasons.

Labor is a large share of cost. The bigger payroll's share of a job's cost, the bigger the effect of leaving part of it out.

Crews are mobilized and demobilized job by job. In many companies, the end of a job means terminations. The cost that stayed hidden for months shows up all at once.

Results are measured by job. A contractor decides price, margin and distributions job by job. If each job carries only part of its cost, every decision is skewed in the same direction: optimistic.

That's one reason actual margin drifts away from estimated margin without anyone being able to explain exactly where the money went.

Accruing means bringing the cost into the month it's incurred

The fix is well known: accrue. Every month, each job recognizes in its cost the share of the 13th salary, vacation, payroll charges and an estimate of severance generated by the workers assigned to it.

In practice, that means:

  • Calculate the accrual by job, not for the company as a whole. The cost has to go where the worker worked that month.
  • Include the payroll charges. Accruing only the 13th salary and vacation without the charges on them still leaves part of the cost out.
  • Estimate severance when demobilization is likely. If the crew will be let go at the end of the job, that cost belongs to the job.
  • Separate cash from the accrual. Accruing records the cost. Setting the money aside to pay it is a separate decision, which should show up in the 13-week cash flow.

Your accountant knows how to do this. The question is whether the information reaches leadership at the job level, which is where decisions are made.

Four questions to ask your finance team

  • 1. Does each job's result include the monthly accrual for the 13th salary, vacation and payroll charges? Or do these costs only show up when they're paid?
  • 2. Which job does the 13th salary paid in December go to? The job the employee is on that month, or the jobs where he worked during the year?
  • 3. Where is severance for a demobilized crew recorded? On the job that closed, or in a general cost center?
  • 4. Did the last profit distribution account for the labor liability accumulated on jobs in progress?

If any answer is uncertain, the profit in the report may be larger than the real profit.

Profit has to pay the whole bill

A job is only profitable if its result covers all the cost it generated, including what hasn't left the bank yet.

Distributing profit before recognizing that cost is spending money that already belongs to someone: the worker who will take vacation, receive the 13th salary or be let go at the end of the job.

Real profit is what's left after everyone is paid. The rest is just cash borrowed from the future.

Explore the Elevare™ Preliminary Assessment.

Renato Lerner, article author and founder of Elevare™

Renato Lerner

Founder, Elevare™

Renato Lerner has 30 years of experience in construction in Brazil, Angola, and the United States. He is the founder of Elevare™ and creator of the Organizational Capability Diagnostic.

Elevare™

Want to know your company's organizational balance?

Schedule a conversation →